Google Labels URL Parameters as Major Cause of Crawl Inefficiency

 This practice, as explained by noted Google analyst Gary Illyes, is the use of something that creates an almost endless number of URLs off of just one web page, hence much to the detriment of the search engine crawlers.

It’s a bigger problem for an e-commerce website, where URL parameters are used to a great degree to dynamically track all sorts of product variations, filter options, and changing customer behaviors. The end result is there are lots of different URLs, but the content they’re pointing at is actually very similar, if not identical. This might be fine for a human searcher, but it makes life very difficult for the search engine crawlers that need to index and rank your pages.

Illyes laid out all the technical details of the problem in a recent episode of the Google Search Off The Record podcast. He explained that while servers can plain and simply ignore such additional parameters, search engine crawlers are not as smart. Well, they end up crawling many URLs, hence wasting a whole lot of the crawl budget and missing important pages.

This has significant SEO implications. A website, e-commerce-related especially, that consumes a big part of its crawl budget processing duplicate URLs can lose many opportunities within search. It can result in reduced organic traffic and revenues, which particularly is the worst-case scenario for e-commerce businesses that rely heavily on the visibility of search engines.

Historically, Google has tried to get around this by using the URL Parameters tool in Search Console. It allowed website owners to specify that some parameters were important and others could be ignored by search engine crawlers. But the tool was deprecated in 2022. The story is so similar to how so many have unfolded in the past with Google leaving many SEOs struggling with just how to handle URL parameters properly.

Illyes hinted at potential solutions currently in the works at Google. Among them are advanced algorithms that will de-duplicate URLs and not count them towards the crawled count, while others focus on better communication channels between Google and website owners to allow for better crawl management, or even website owners using robots.txt files more effectively to help guide crawlers to important pages.

While some of these prospective solutions offer a glimmer of hope for a better tomorrow, there definitely remains no room for complacency. Much of it boils down to the proactivity of URL structure optimization and parameter management that you undertake. This simply involves being dexterous with your parameters, maintaining clear URL hierarchies, and ensuring canonical tags detail the preferred version of the page.

In addition, webmasters really need to pay attention to their crawl budget and potential problems regarding URL parameters. The testing can be done with tools like Google Search Console, which enables real insights into crawling behavior and detecting where possible improvements can be made.

Handling URL parameters will almost certainly be one of the complicated issues that future digital landscapes will be facing. However, website owners can diminish the impact and control it to the extent that it will not significantly affect the visibility of a website and will thus be able to reach its target audience by fully understanding the impact and taking appropriate measures.

Impact of URL Parameters on SEO: Understanding

This, however, will not be very recommended, as too much use of URL parameters will place an undesirable influence on the SEO performance of a website. By generating an overwhelming number of URLs, the following can be achieved:

• Wastage of Crawl Budget – Search engine crawlers waste valuable resources in processing redundant URLs. In doing this, it diverts attention from important pages.
• Reduced Indexing – If the crawl budget is used up, possibly critical pages cannot be indexed properly.
• Lower Search Rankings: Websites that may have inefficient crawl budgets may suffer from low search engine rankings because of less visibility by the search engines.
• User Experience Issues: Depending on usage, the URL parameters can produce very confusing and lengthy URLs that are served by bad user experience.
• The website owners ought to take greater care of creating illustrative, clean, and user-friendly URLs. A valid URL structure with minimum unnecessary parameters assists sites to maximize the SEO and users’ experience.

Best Practices to Manage URL Parameters

• Parameters should be kept minimum: Practically use parameters wherever it is relevant, removing multiple variations
• Have a Clean URL structure: Create a rational and easily understandable URL hierarchy.
• Canonical Tags: These specify the preferred version of a page to avoid issues of duplicated content
• . Monitor Crawl Budget: Track crawl behavior to identify potential problems or issues. Robots.txt: Instructions that direct the search engine crawlers, giving them directions on which pages on the site are important
• . Regularly check for updates as per Google’s guidelines and algorithm updates relevant to URL parameters. If web owners consider the above mentioned best practices, they will efficiently work with URL parameters and efficiently work towards SERP optimization.

The Impact of URL Parameters on User Experience

The use of URL parameters, besides negatively impacting search engines technically, also greatly affects the user experience. Lengthy, clumsy URLs, loaded with tracking parameters and session identifiers, can often deter users and create usability hurdles on a website. Users share URLs on social media or through email frequently, and an unsightly URL can seriously hurt brand perception.

In addition, URL parameters also contribute to link rot, a situation where links get broken or outdated. Since the parameters have changed over time, shared links can just lead to error pages or other forms of content that are irrelevant. Apart from annoyance to users, this can also lead to a bad reputation for a website.

Dynamic Rendering

Now, one of the things that have recently worsened with the URL parameters is the SEO relation. Dynamic rendering is a technique of providing a search engine crawler with a different content representation than that presented to the user through a human-browser. This might be applied in good faith — let’s say, to prepare custom content before delivering it to the users who request it through the appropriate interface — but it also might be misused with the intent to deceive search engines about ranking-worthy content.

Google also explicitly frowned upon cloaking, which refers to showing different contents to search engines and users. Heavy reliance on dynamic rendering and the overuse of URL parameters can classify as spamming signals and incur some form of penalty.

Balancing User Experience and SEO

For the holistic approach to work with URL parameters towards search engine optimization and user experience, the following factors need to be worked out carefully:

• URL structure: Try to maintain clean, descriptive, and user-friendly URLs. Avoid using too many parameters; go for meaningful segments, because that only makes the content of every page descriptive.
• Parameter Management: If you really need parameters to drive the functionality, then server-side redirects, or even JavaScript, can be used to clean up those URLs on the user’s end, while keeping the information in place for tracking purposes.
• Canonicalization: Add canonical tags to show the preferred version where multiple URLs exist owing to parameters.
• User Testing — continuously test the user experience of a website to highlight any issues with the URL structure and parameters.
• Dynamic Rendering — use dynamic rendering cautiously, always delivering relevant content to the search engine, and never use cloaking.
• A judicious balance between SEO and user experience makes a website both user-friendly and search engine-friendly.

The Future of URL Parameters

As search engine technology evolves, URL parameter management will keep getting more sophisticated. Google and others are making major investments in artificial intelligence and machine learning to understand website content and user intent better. As good as these seem to be and could avert some of the challenges that come with the presence of URL parameters, the site owners should never be relaxed.

Therefore, it’s vital to keep up with search engine algorithms and best practices for webmasters to ensure that their websites remain competitive and are a good match for users.

In the end, modern SEO places special significance on handling URL parameters correctly because the consequences for search engines and users are well understood. Optimizing a website’s URL is one way a webmaster can go about ensuring proper handling and optimization for a search engine and user satisfaction. It is indeed possible to create websites with the best search engine rankings as well as good user engagements by structuring URLs, setting parameters, and taking care of user experiences.

Sources:

• https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-warns-url-parameters-create-crawl-issues/523982/
• https://intechsea.com/google-warns-that-url-parameters-cause-crawl-issues/
• https://userp.io/news/google-says-url-parameters-create-crawling-inefficiencies/
• https://www.reddit.com/r/SEO_Digital_Marketing/comments/1enrogl/google_warns_ecommerce_sites_url_parameters/

Subscribe to our newsletter