Robots.txt: Not a Security Shield, Warns Google’s Gary Illyes

It’s crucial that SEOs and website owners understand what robots.txt really is for.

As Google’s Gary Illyes did point out in a tweet recently, “Robots.txt is not for security.” It is misconceived by many as the digital gatekeeper; the directive is supposed to simply inform search engine crawlers about what to index and what to stay away from. Illyes felt compelled to say that robots.txt provides zero security against undesired access by malicious bots or even people.

These are findings that highlight some major weakness in a lot of strategies on website security. Though the robots.txt file finds its place within SEO, there should be proper understanding of the limitations it has. Relying on this particular file to protect sensitive information in its entirety definitely leaves websites open to exploitation.

Understanding Robots.txt

Unless one understands what robots.txt is and what it is not, the problem will not be fully grasped. It is essentially a text file placed in the root directory of a website, which search engines refer to in order to know which URLs to crawl and index. Special instructions within this file make it possible to disallow certain pages or directories from search engine crawlers by a website owner.

This is to say that it’s not a firewall. Though it informs search engines of pages that should be avoided, this won’t stop anyone from accessing your website. Malicious bots, hackers, and even regular internet users can still visit your site despite what you have specified in your robots.txt file.

Need of Better Security Measures

Considering the weakness of robots.txt, it becomes imperative for any website owner to have strong security measures that safeguard digital assets. This shall be well strategized by starting with a firewall. Firewalls block access to a website through the monitoring of all the incoming and outgoing network traffic.

Another important module of a website’s security is password protection. Access to the sensitive areas of a site can be inhibited by requiring a password to access those areas. WAFs also offer an extended layer of protection by filtering and monitoring HTTP traffic.

Beyond Robots.txt: An Integrated Approach to Security

Illyes’ statement is simply a pointer to the fact that the issue of website security is multi-dimensional. While robots.txt remains as a very good tool for SEO, one shouldn’t rely solely on it for protection.

Periodic Security Audits: Regular security assessments should be conducted to discover vulnerabilities and to take remedial measures to protect against them.

Employee Education: Employees must be educated on the best practices of cyber security to prevent the human element from coming into play.

Keeping Software Up-to-Date: The software must be current with security patches, including both the CMS itself and the various plugins that are in place.

Back up regularly: Implement a regular backup of the data so that it can be restored in case of security breaches.

Dangerous Over-Reliance on Robots.txt

Above is a very sharp reminder from Illyes that SEO and security differ in their nature. While both are protecting and taking care of a website, they use very different strategies. Whereas SEO aims at improving visibility and ranking of a site, security protects data and systems from unauthorized access.

This means that probably the feature of robots.txt, which could have led to the misconception of it being a source of security on a website, is the content access control. In this case, the access control only applies to search engines and doesn’t apply within the Internet at large. Malicious actors can easily bypass robots.txt with the sophisticated tools and techniques at their disposal.

Moreover, increasing reliance on robots.txt does not help SEO at all. It certainly helps in keeping sensitive or duplicate content beyond the reach of indexing by search engines; however, overblocking definitely creates a barrier to discoverability. Huge indexes are used by search engines to generate relevant results; hence, limiting their access to your content hurts your search rankings.

The Role of Human Intervention in Website Security

It is well said that technology is important, but it is not perfect. Human input becomes very necessary to keep the digital space safe. This shall include technical expertise with an underpinning of policies in implementation and an element of employee training.

This makes regular security audits indispensable in finding out the loopholes. Such audit shall be done by professionals and skilled experts who can measure the effectiveness of the security measures in place and suggest better implementing options. The employees should be trained to use their discretionary abilities in identifying and reverting against threats. Phishing attacks, social engineering, and insider threats are pretty common, and a well-informed workforce is the first line of defense.

Beyond Firewalls: A Multi-Layered Security Approach

While firewalls are important, they represent just one layer in the security mechanism. Other tools in intrusion detection and intrusion prevention systems monitor network traffic to identify suspicious activity. These systems enable the detection and blocking of attacks before system damage has actually occurred.

More importantly, sensitive data should be protected using encryption. Enforced HTTPS will help to protect the communication between a website and a user’s browser. Consider additional encryption of data at rest, including customer information and financial data, to safeguard against possible unauthorized access.

The Ever-Changing Threat Landscape

The world of cybersecurity is constantly in flux. New dangers come up every single day, not to mention that existing ones are constantly evolving. To be able to always be one step ahead of the bad guys, a business has to be on its toes as far as security is concerned. This ranges from keeping up with the latest threats to attending congresses concerning the industry, training employees on an ongoing basis.

Apart from this, organizations should promote the culture of security awareness. A lot of exposure to risk can be reduced by a business if employees are encouraged to report any suspicious activities and to implement safe practices.

The Future of Website Security

As technology evolves, so will the methods that cybercriminals use. Artificial intelligence and machine learning already show their faces in how more sophisticated attacks are built. Businesses have to come up with such technologies for both offense and defense in relation to these threats.

Artificial intelligence makes it possible to analyze huge amounts of data for patterns indicative of malicious activity. Machine learning algorithms adjust to these new threats and protect in real-time. More than that, blockchain technology has a few ways to provide effective solutions regarding secure data management and transfer.

Areas that are increasingly gaining importance are certainly the integration of cybersecurity into the development lifecycle. Security can be built into the system from its very beginning. This technique is called “DevSecOps,” focusing on close collaboration among development, security, and operations teams.

Conclusion

Admission by Google of the weaknesses in robots.txt enforces the requirement for a holistic, evolving security strategy. If one considers SEO and security with respect to a website, one can say that both protect the interests of the website; however, the approaches are totally different. A multi-layer security framework coupled with an understanding of the weaknesses of the robots.txt file is quite effective in reducing the risk of cyber threats to a business.

The future of security is where technology overlaps with human expertise. Next-generation technologies coupled with a culture of security awareness will leave organizations well-armed against the evolving panorama of threats.

Sources:

• https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-confirms-robots-txt-is-ineffective-against-unauthorized-access/523632/
• https://intechsea.com/google-confirms-robots-txt-cant-prevent-unauthorized-access/
• https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4769140/robots-txt-user-agent-googlebot-disallow-google-still-indexing
• https://www.onely.com/blog/blocked-by-robots-txt-search-console/#:~:text=Google%20Search%20Console%3F-,%E2%80%9CBlocked%20by%20robots.,as%20your%20website%20gets%20bigger.

Subscribe to our newsletter