WordPress Foundation Files for Trademark on ‘Managed WordPress’ and ‘Hosted WordPress’

Source: Freepik_Free Vector _ Abstract creative website hosting illustration

WordPress Foundation filed trademark applications for the phrases ‘Managed WordPress’ and ‘Hosted WordPress’. The significance of such applications to the WordPress ecosystem is undeniably monumental, as approval might mean the latter could no longer be used by web hosts or plugin developers commercially-which could have farreaching implications on nearly any business.

The trademark applications, filed in July 2024, cover various goods and services from web hosting, including servers, software platforms, cloud hosting, SaaS services, website management software, and plugins. The application sought to claim all these terms, which would eventually mean that the WordPress Foundation was claiming legal ownership over their usage.

Possible Aftermath for Web Hosts and Plugin Developers

This would significantly impact web hosts and plugin developers who are using the phrases ‘Managed WordPress’ or ‘Hosted WordPress’ in marketing blurbs or product names. They would have to seek permission from the WordPress Foundation or, more likely, pay licensing fees in order to continue using them.

This will likely burden web hosts and developers of various plugins with a greater cost, which may affect their profit margins and competitiveness. It may also throw confusion and perplexity in the WordPress sphere of operations by compelling businesses to amend and restructure their brand and marketing related policies to avoid potential legal implications.

Expectations from Business Representatives

This can raise various issues in the business sector’s opinions.

While this has elicited protest from the industry players as they argue that ‘Managed WordPress’ and ‘Hosted WordPress’ are generally descriptive terms, and thus exclusively owned by no one, the trademark applications filed by the WordPress Foundation have turned contentious.

Other industry experts also have further concerns over the trademark abuse powers that the WordPress Foundation could abuse to gain dominance in the WordPress world. These can be used as selfish ways, for example, to ensure maximum profit instead of considering the interest of the majority.

Role of Automattic

Even though the trademark applications are filed by the WordPress Foundation, it is pretty sure that for-profit company Automattic, the maker of WordPress.com, will largely figure into the exercise of these rights. Automattic has long made a point of exerting control in the WordPress ecosystem, and they might use this trademark to wring some sort of leverage to squeeze even more money from web hosts and plugin developers.

Next Steps and Possible Outcomes

After the filing of the trademark applications, the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) is currently examining them. Third parties may get a chance to file objections to the applications at some point, and the USPTO may have to make a final determination regarding whether or not to grant the trademarks.

As long as the trademarks are approved, WordPress Foundation and Automattic would be able to use them in order to file a lawsuit against companies who violate their rights. This would leave an uncertain climate within the WordPress environment since companies may not go about using either ‘Managed WordPress’ or ‘Hosted WordPress’ terms for fear of being dragged into a courtroom.

Within the past week, WordPress Foundation filed applications for trademarking the terms ‘Managed WordPress’ and ‘Hosted WordPress,’ which caused a public outcry among the WordPress community. If approved, these would significantly influence web hosting, plugins, and more regarding the entire WordPress ecosystem.

Increased Costs and Greater Stringency

Industry stakeholders immediately flag and raise their alarm over increased costs and their limitations. If WordPress Foundation can trademark these words, it’s going to get licensing fees from any web host and any plugin developer who uses them. When that happens, customers will bear the cost on their backs as web hosts will have no alternative but to pass the extra costs.

Secondly, the Foundation can impose a limitation of how they are employed. For example, it may instruct them to avoid using it at all in specific instances or even bar business as usual except where certain guidelines are observed. That will definitely suffocate innovation and creativity for web hosts and plugin developers alike.

Impact on Competition

The trademarking of ‘Managed WordPress’ and ‘Hosted WordPress’ can also strongly influence competition in the WordPress environment. By controlling the usage of these terms, the WordPress Foundation manages to effectively create entry barriers for new entrants in the WordPress environment. It would prove inconvenient to small and medium businesses that cannot afford the heavier weight of setting up licensing negotiations or finding alternative branding strategies against larger players.

Moreover, the Foundation’s actions may consolidate the power in the WordPress community at the expense of diversity. The market will be less competitive, with fewer opportunities for innovation and more limited options available for web hosts and for plugins.

Open Source Values

The trademark claims by the WordPress Foundation contradict open-source values, which made possible for the platform of WordPress to develop and thrive. Open-source applications are free, open distribution, collaborative, and community-driven developments. Thus, the move of the Foundation to hold control over certain terms is away from the tenets of open source and as far as away from proprietary models.

This may have bad consequences on the long-term health of the WordPress community. The users will generally contribute less to its development or recommend it to others if they feel that the platform has become less open and more restrictive. This will eventually be a general decrease in its popularity and relevance.

The Call for Balance

Although the WordPress Foundation may have some valid concerns about the misuse of the brand, it must not take an overly controlling stand. Rather, the Foundation needs to work toward promoting the growth and development of the WordPress ecosystem.

Another course of action could involve the Foundation laying out regulations regarding the use of ‘Managed WordPress’ and ‘Hosted WordPress,’ rather than depending solely on establishing trademark rights. Rules might make possible the proper and possibly even beneficial use of terms to foster consistency while also maintaining this equilibrium between encouraging innovation and competitiveness.

Apart from this, the Foundation can partner with WordPress community members to develop more diversified branding strategies that web hosts and plugin developers could utilize instead. This will further help in reducing dependence on the terms ‘Managed WordPress’ and ‘Hosted WordPress’. Diversity and competition will improve in the market.

The Future of WordPress

The trademark applications for the WordPress Foundation will no doubt directly impact the future of the WordPress platform, whether they are successful or not. Imagine if the Foundation successfully enforces trademarks on these terms that increase costs, reduce competition and, in the end, dilute the more open and innovative nature of the ecosystem.

Still, hope springs eternal that a better balance can still be found in the way WordPress operates. Engaging with the WordPress community, ensuring the continuing development of the platform, and increasing the recognition of WordPress growth sets up the Foundation for the successful guarantee of WordPress being a vibrant, thriving open-source platform for decades to come.

Sources:

• https://www.searchenginejournal.com/wordpress-files-to-trademark-managed-wordpress-hosted-wordpress/528112/
• https://r.search.yahoo.com/_ylt=Awr1QGoQOvVmCAQAcJi7HAx.;_ylu=Y29sbwNzZzMEcG9zAzIEdnRpZAMEc2VjA3Ny/RV=2/RE=1728556816/RO=10/RU=https%3a%2f%2fswitchpointdesign.com%2fwordpress-files-to-trademark-managed-wordpress-hosted-wordpress%2f/RK=2/RS=ahwV08VpKqvn4gFpx1B1m2OGeOQ-
• https://r.search.yahoo.com/_ylt=Awr1QGoQOvVmCAQAd5i7HAx.;_ylu=Y29sbwNzZzMEcG9zAzMEdnRpZAMEc2VjA3Ny/RV=2/RE=1728556816/RO=10/RU=https%3a%2f%2ftechcrunch.com%2f2024%2f09%2f25%2flegal-ping-pong-in-the-wordpress-world-continues-automattic-now-sends-wp-engine-a-cease-and-desist-letter-alleging-trademark-infringement%2f/RK=2/RS=wtgz_Vaiu_InsN8kj_bOUYEC.yI-
• https://r.search.yahoo.com/_ylt=Awr1QGoQOvVmCAQAfZi7HAx.;_ylu=Y29sbwNzZzMEcG9zAzYEdnRpZAMEc2VjA3Ny/RV=2/RE=1728556816/RO=10/RU=https%3a%2f%2fcommunity.enhance.com%2fd%2f2015-wordpress-trademarks/RK=2/RS=1K7SSoTkOuA8zCm2Egx50FLfzKg-

Subscribe to our newsletter